Terri Schiavo and Us

Pastor Robert Fleischmann, National Director, Christian Life Resources


On February 25, 1990, Terri Schiavo collapsed in her home. Doctors believe a potassium imbalance caused her heart to stop and restricted oxygen flow to her brain. She suffered serious brain damage. She was 26-years-old.

In November 1992, Terris husband, Michael, won a malpractice suit against the doctors and was awarded approximately $1 million: 70% to provide for Terris life-long care and 30% for loss of companionship.

On February 14, 1993, Terris parents and her husband disagreed on the manner in which the money was being used for Terris care. The parents effort to be named Terris legal guardians failed, and the husband continued in that role.

In May 1998, her husband presented the first petition to the court to remove Terri from tube feeding.

Since that time a variety of details, gossip, and rumor arose. The relevance of such talk does not overshadow the fact that Terris life hangs in the balance between those who wish her feeding to continue and those who wish it to be stopped.

What do these circumstances have to do with you? Although you do not personally know Terri, you have this in common: at one time or another you may have said something like, “I dont want to live like that.” Michael claims Terri, before her 1990 collapse, used words to that effect in response to the Karen Ann Quinlan case (a woman who in the 1980s was on a form of life support). Based on Terris words, a judge ruled she should no longer be fed.

All of us are now threatened. In our observations, there are many things in life we wish would not to happen to us. We do not wish to be poor. We do not wish to be disfigured in an accident. We do not wish to be publicly shamed. We do not wish to be disliked by anyone. We do not wish to be a burden on loved ones. We do not wish to ever become a diabetic. The list could go on and on. Yet, not wishing for something is not the same as authorizing the taking of our lives.

In the case of Terri Schiavo, we know what the husband wants. We know what the parents want. We know what some of the courts want, and we know what the Florida governor and most legislators want. We may even think we know what Terri wants. What is not being asked is, “What would God want?”

The Christian community is tied by its name and by its faith to seek the direction of God. That doesnt mean we always like what God has to say. After all, imperfect people often differ with the perfect Creator. It also doesnt mean the answer comes easily. Our own biases shade the way we read Gods Word.

In this case the Word of God is clear. The prohibition to killing is codified in the commandments. It is explicit in such passages as Genesis 9:6, “Whoever sheds the blood of man, by man shall his blood be shed; for in the image of God has God made man.” Without Gods expressed command or permission, we cannot take human life. Not even our own.

Gods Word also speaks strongly against playing favorites. We are told in James 2:9, “But if you show favoritism, you sin and are convicted by the law as lawbreakers.” We cannot prejudice those whose quality of life may be diminished.

Gods Word directs us to assume the burdens of others who need our attention and concern. In Acts 20:35 we are directed, “We must help the weak, remembering the words the Lord Jesus himself said: It is more blessed to give than to receive.”

Finally, even when hardship comes our way we are encouraged to practice contentment, patience, and trust. That encouragement is rooted in the fact that the challenges and hardships of this life are considered “light and momentary troubles” (2 Corinthians 4:17) in comparison with the eternal life we have in Christ (Romans 8:18).

The removal of Terri Schiavos feeding is wrong. It is wrong not because of the various motivations her husband may have for doing so. It is wrong not because it is unclear what Terri really meant by saying she would not want to live in this condition. It is wrong because it is clear God is not taking her life. God does not permit us to stop carrying the burdens of others. It is wrong because God calls us to help when we can.

To feed Terri Schiavo is the right thing, not only because it is compassionate and loving. It is the right thing because of Gods clear and compelling Word. It is the right thing because God has promised to work out even the harshest of lifes experiences for the good of those who love Him (Romans 8:28).

Every Christian looks for opportunities to share Gods Word. It becomes clearer with the passage of time that near lifes end, the Christian witness cannot be muted. It must be heard and understood. While no one wants to live a diminished quality of life, no Christian ever wants to do anything contrary to the will of God. In this regard Christians must be clear.

One powerful testimony on the value of human life and Gods will regarding it, is to sign a medical directive statement. A few years back Christian Life Resources worked with members of the legal community to draft Christian medical statements which were customized for all 50 states.

The case of Terri Schiavo is a sharp reminder of the importance of signing such statements to provide clear direction as to our desires and any course of action for our continued care in the light of Gods Word.

NOTE: Terri Schiavo died March 31, 2005 after enduring a 13-day court-ordered starvation.


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *